As YouTube’s community responds to the swirling controversy regarding LonelyGirl15, the bigger questions come into play. It’s not all about is she/isn’t she real, who is she, where is she, it’s about - can a company achieve marketing success after getting people to get involved and end up feeling ‘duped’ in the whole affair?

mandydale 'YouTube's LonelyGirl15 Causes a Stir'

Will lonelygirl15 be lonely after all? Mandydale talks about the implications for marketers:

When it comes to advertising, there has been a current debate on whether it is ok to essentially hide the true origin of a campaign in a online teaser or viral component, or whether the true intent and message should be transparent to the audience. The repercussions of keeping the true intent (i.e. marketing campaign, advertisment for a movie, etc.) from the audience could include the potential of the viewers feeling alienated or angry by being duped. And that, could cause serious brand management issues.

mandydale » Blog Archive » youtube’s lonelygirl15 causes a stir